I just returned from a meeting of the UT Gender and Sexuality Center. Kim Pearson and her son Shawn, of
TransYouth Family Allies spoke to a small group of us. It was really astounding. Some interesting snippets. Most people, when you mention trans or gender identity issues act as if it is a very rare and uncommon thing to happen (if they've heard of it at all). Most of the research on gender variance was done 30 years ago solely on men transitioning surgically to women. Kim said that historically 80% of people experiencing some measure of gender dysphoria didn't transition at all, but stayed closeted**** (See Kim's correct comments in the comment area.)
Current research is actually spotty, but estimates range from 1 in 500 to 1-250 people born do not fit the "binary" model of a boy's boy or a girl's girl. Maybe some of my peeps out there know more than I do, but that's what Kim's research had shown.
For comparison, she showed some stats on diseases that get shitloads of attention. Juvenile Diabetes occurs in every 1 of 2000 people. Cystic Fibrosis, 1 in 13,000.
Not that she was in any way comparing gender identity issues to diseases mind you, but just to shed light on a myth that "it doesn't happen to anyone". It apparently happens quite a bit.
Kids know extremely early who they are. Gender identity isn't sexual orientation, or I should say they aren't necessarily the same thing. I've always "known" for example that I was comfy as a girl, happy to be a girl. My best friend Amy, back in S.C. was not. In the two years I knew her, never wore girly clothes, cut her hair butch short and talked about wanting to be a boy. She was 7 when I met her. If the desire to be different is persistent and consistent and there are acute reactions to having to "be your born gender", Kim says it ain't no phase. I believe that.
The other thing I found interesting were her stories of her son Shawn. Shawn was born biologically female but from an early age, was incredibly resistant to dresses, dolls, long hair etc. Her family rallied early and accepted Shawn's "odd" behavior and he thrived, basically living as a boy until puberty. Lots of things went wrong as his body changed towards bio female, but his mind didn't. Anxiety and depression wreaked havoc on him until finally he came out and explained how he felt.
The best thing she said was that she considered him an "affirmed male" that he didn't have to transition so much as the family had to. And they did. They've taken extremely good care of him through a very rough patch. I found that incredibly respectful. "He didn't have to transition, he was already who he was, we had to." He's a very well spoken cute young man.
So her non-profit was focused specifically on the little "t's" of the world. Kids who as young as 8 have such gender dysphoria that they are suicidal. A 5 year old that she spoke of actually thought he could be a girl if he just didn't have a penis. You can imagine what he tried, unsucessfully thank goodness, to do to himself.
She wasn't advocating just having kids pass as one gender instead of the other, not at all. She realized that the idea of early transitioning through hormones could be viewed by some as asking someone to pick one pole of the binary model. Lots of trans people don't want that. They want to be trans and obviously so, some are gender queer, some want to transition fully into "female" or "male" as notated culturally. Even more so, many of us noted in the discussion, we'd like to work on creating a world where a cis-male can have feminine attributes or a cis-female, male attributes. Where gender identity is allowed to range on a wider continuum. And personally? Where Owen can have a baby doll and not have to worry about getting his ass kicked.
Her agency is devoted to preventing suicides and violence in the community of trans kids. I applaud her for that.
It was an amazing presentation and I really felt so proud to be there and so proud of her as a mother and someone who could see past culturally layered on bull, in order to just love her kid and let him be who he was.
The last bit was chilling to me though. Kenneth Zucker is chairing the committee to revise the DSM's entry on Gender Identity issues. Check
this out for exposing his bias, and this on his belief that
maternal psychopathy is to blame. Of course it is.
Dr. Norman Spack, in contrast wants to offer GID kids the opportunity to transition, or begin the transition early in life. Here is a
Q and A on that...and an
NPR article on him and one on
him and Zucker and how the treatments differ. I'd be going with Dr. Spack, though the right wingers are comparing him to Mengele. Nice.
Anyway, I know I'm an idealist, and I know the fear based answer to this question, but why is it such a fucking big deal??? How does your gender change mine? How does your gay marriage make my marriage somehow null and void.
I suppose it's the cooties right? Like I'm sure I'm covered with all kinds of trans cooties at the moment and they are going to spread.
Kim said, at the very end that she goes to a reading group once a month, and there are a couple of women involved that will not look at her or touch her. Ain't that the shit? What a awesome meeting and what an awesome woman.
I'd rather have trans cooties than fundamentalist bigot cooties, that's for sure.